Contact Us

We would love to hear from you.

Call Now



Our Insurance Companies


About Us

The Dick Butler Insurance Agency has been servicing the Mattoon/Charleston and surrounding area for over 60 years of which Dick Butler has been working with insurance for 42 years, Steve Simmonds for 50 years, and Linda Brandt for 22 years. The Dick Butler Insurance Agency has over 100 years of combined experience in the insurance industry.  We answer the phone during normal business hours. You will never get an answering machine. We are here to help you find the right insurance plan to fit your needs and we strive to offer the best customer service. Our vision is to provide “Quality Insurance Properly Written” to each and every customer!

Dick Butler is a member of the Professional Insurance Counselors Inc, a member of the Illinois Independent Insurance Agent, a member of the Professional Independent Insurance Agents of Illinois, and a resident of Mattoon. We are a member of the Mattoon Chamber of Commerce.

Our agents will work with you to find the right type of insurance for all of your needs. Everyone has different needs and we assess the situation, discuss your options to find the right solution for you. We work with many insurance companies to provide the best insurance coverage and best rates.

Contact Us

Our Headquarters 620 Lakeland
Mattoon, IL 61938

Speak to Us 217-235-4096
217-235-4090 - Fax


Email Us


Mon - Fri 9 am - 5pm

Send us an Email